Weighing the value of repatriation against future scientific research

How are museum objects valued and who decides? Trevor Engel explores the relationship of perceived scientific value to the idea of hoarding applied to colonial institutions' holdings.

By juxtaposing the possibilities of future scientific value with the value that these objects (primarily bodies) have held and still hold to their respective communities, I ask whose perception of value matters when it comes to deciding on what (or whom) stays in these collections.

Trevor Engel uses examples from amongst others:
  • The Mütter Museum in Philadelphia (over 35,000 specimens, ranging from slides with microscopical diseases to historical medical tools, human fetuses, and entire skeletons)
  • The Warren Anatomical Museum at Harvard University (15,000 specimens today, where the 954 specimens listed in the 1848 catalog from the Boston Society for Medical Improvement now reside.)
  • The Berlin Museum of Medical History at the Charité in Berlin, (over 23,000 specimens in 1901).