Cambridge’s return of 100 Benin bronzes puts British Museum on the spot

Barnaby Phillips: The decision by the university’s Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology to return looted Nigerian treasures leaves larger institutions increasingly isolated. Which museum will be the next one?

Ownership of more than 116 sculptures looted from Benin by the British military in 1897 has been transferred to Nigeria by Cambridge University’s Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology (MAA).

This move will increase pressure on other British institutions to follow suit.

The sculptures include several impressive commemorative heads depicting kings of Benin, or obas, plaques depicting warriors and animals, smaller pendant masks and highly decorated armlets.

The museum’s director, Nicholas Thomas, told The Observer that after “thorough and robust consideration [the] overwhelming view” was that it should relinquish ownership of all 116 Benin objects taken in 1897.

About 100 are expected shortly to be sent to Nigeria, at the university’s cost; the rest will stay in the MAA on long-term loan.

The director general of Nigeria’s National Commission for Museums and Monuments (NCMM), Olugbile Holloway, said he now expected a “domino effect” of artefacts being returned, including from the British Museum, which has 900 Benin bronzes, the world’s largest collection. “The issue has come to their doorstep,” he added.

Political disputes in Nigeria have complicated the process, with the respective interests of the federal government’s NCMM, the state government in Benin City and the current oba, Ewuare II.

Nigeria’s government museums, which are grossly underfunded, have struggled to display the returned bronzes. But Holloway said the privately funded renovation of Nigeria’s National Museum in Lagos – due to be finished in March, and where many of the bronzes from Cambridge will be displayed – will be “completely different… We want to use Lagos as a model, a proof of concept, and the pictures of it will speak for themselves”.

The focus in Britain is now likely to fall on Oxford’s Pitt Rivers Museum, where, also in 2022, the university supported a claim for the return of 97 bronzes.

The National Museum of Scotland has also been in discussion with the NCMM over the return of its own collection.

This leaves the British Museum increasingly isolated, not just in relation to the Benin bronzes, but on the wider issue of how it handles objects taken by force.